2-slice toaster
The right product, without the BS. 5 tested.
⭐ 4.5
High-End
Best 2-slice toaster – Nostalgia RTOS200
Toast your way to retro heaven with this quirky red toaster.
Why we chose it:
"It's a toaster. It toasts. But wait, there's more! It’s red. That’s like Ferraris for your bread. Plus, it's retro, because everything was better back then, right? With five browning levels, you'll feel like a toast whisperer. It’s not just a toaster; it's a lifestyle choice. Or at least a desperate attempt to feel something while having breakfast. The crumb tray is a revelation for the lazy. Who knew crumbs needed so much attention? At 900 watts, it's the caffeine shot your mornings need, minus the jitters. It promises to toast bagels without needing a PhD in toaster operation. And hey, it's got a cord storage. Because nothing says 'organized adult' like a hidden cord. Embrace the nostalgia, because modern life is overrated."
⭐ 4.3
Budget
Best 2-slice toaster – Proctor Silex 22215G
Proctor Silex Toaster, 2 slices, extra-wide slots, cool walls, black/white. Toast perfection with a dash of irony.
Why we chose it:
"Meet the Proctor Silex 2-Slice Toaster, a masterpiece of budget engineering cloaked in a plastic shell. It doesn't just toast bread; it embraces it with extra-wide slots like a long-lost friend. Let's be honest, its best feature is not the toasting but the Toast Boost, which catapults your English muffins to new heights. The automatic shutoff is a gentle nod to your forgetful nature, saving you from a kitchen inferno. And, as a cherry on top, the crumb tray ensures your counters don't resemble a breadcrumb crime scene. Sure, it won't serenade you with its elegance, but for those who value function over form, this little machine is a quiet hero in disguise."
⭐ 4.4
Performance
Best 2-slice toaster – Kitchmix EP-SV0011-2
KitchMix Retro Toaster with wide slots, 6 settings, perfect for bagels. 825W power, in stylish black stainless steel.
Why we chose it:
"Looking for a toaster that screams 'I was made in the 50s!' but functions in the 2020s? Meet the KitchMix Retro Toaster. It's like your grandma's kitchen got a tech upgrade. With 6 settings, it's got more toast shades than your last beach vacation. Those slots are wide enough to accommodate everything from Texas toast to bagels, which means you can finally stop squishing your bread to fit. It's got a crumb tray that won't make cleaning a chore, unlike literally every other toaster ever. And hey, it even offers safety features, because apparently, not burning your house down is trendy now. At 51 bucks, it's almost a steal—except you're the one getting toasted."
⭐ 4.3
Luxury
Best 2-slice toaster – Nostalgia INSPIREX
Smart toaster with touchscreen for those who like their toast precise and fancy.
Why we chose it:
"This Inspirex toaster thinks it's a smartphone. It's not just bread, it's an experience. You get to touch a screen and feel like a tech mogul while deciding exactly how brown you like your toast. It's the Rolls Royce of toasters with a countdown timer that will make you feel like you're launching a space shuttle, not toasting a bagel. It has more settings than your average mobile game, so you'll never be bored with your breakfast. It’s not just about toasting, it’s about making a statement: ‘I’m too cool to use a dial.’ Plus, it promises a uniform grill. Because who doesn't want their toast to look like it was ironed by a perfectionist?"
⭐ 4.5
Indecent
Best 2-slice toaster – Smeg TSF01GRUS
Retro design meets toast in Smeg's 2-slice toaster. Style and function collide.
Why we chose it:
"You want style over substance but still demand some substance? Meet the Smeg toaster. It's not just a pretty face; it's a pretty face that toasts bread. In a world where toasters are mostly uninspired metal boxes, Smeg is the peacock strutting in the kitchen. With six browning levels, it's like having a personal tanning salon for your bread. And those wide slots? They're the VIP lounge for bagels and waffles. Sure, it won't write a novel for you, but it will make your breakfast slightly less dull. The self-centering racks are like a GPS for your toast, ensuring it doesn't wander off into the abyss. It's not the cheapest toaster on the market, but who needs savings when you have style?"